PARIS (AP) — The Syrian squaddies got here first, at night time, for the son, Patrick, a 20-year-old psychology scholar at Damascus College, and stated they have been taking him away for wondering.
They got here again the following night time for his father, Mazen.
5 years later, in 2018, loss of life certificate from Syrian government showed to the Dabbagh circle of relatives that the French-Syrian father and son would by no means come house once more.
In a landmark trial, a Paris courtroom is looking for this week to resolve whether or not Syrian intelligence officers — probably the most senior to move on trial in a Ecu courtroom over crimes allegedly dedicated all the way through the rustic’s civil battle — have been chargeable for their disappearance and deaths.
The four-day hearings began Tuesday and are anticipated to air chilling allegations that President Bashar Assad’s authorities has broadly used torture and arbitrary detentions to carry directly to energy all the way through the war, now in its 14th yr.
The French trial comes as Assad has been regaining an air of secrecy of world respectability, beginning to shed his longtime standing as a pariah that stemmed from the violence unleashed on his warring parties. Human rights teams which are events to the French case hope it’ll refocus consideration on alleged atrocities.
Right here’s a have a look at the ones concerned:
THE ACCUSED
— Ali Mamlouk, former head of the Nationwide Safety Bureau overseeing Syrian safety and intelligence services and products. Allegedly labored without delay with Assad. Now in his overdue 70s.
— Jamil Hassan, former Air Drive intelligence director. Survivors attesting within the case allege having noticed him at a detention heart within the capital, Damascus, the place the Dabbaghs are idea to had been held. In his early 70s.
— Salam Mahmoud, in his mid-60s, a former investigations professional at a Damascus army airport believed to accommodate the detention heart. Mahmoud is said to have expropriated the Dabbaghs’ space once they have been taken away.
The 3 males are accused of scary crimes in opposition to humanity, giving directions to devote them and permitting subordinates to devote them throughout the alleged arrest, torture and killing of the daddy and son. In addition they are accused of confiscating their space and of placing Air Drive intelligence services and products on the disposal of people that allegedly killed them.
The accused are being attempted in absentia. French magistrates issued arrest warrants for them in October 2018, in spite of acknowledging that there was once little chance in their extradition to France. There have been no protection attorneys to constitute them because the hearings were given underway Tuesday morning. French magistrates decided they don’t have diplomatic immunity.
“The 3 other folks accused are very senior officers of the Syrian gadget of repression and torture. This offers a selected tone to this trial. They aren’t small fish,” stated Patrick Baudouin, a attorney for rights teams concerned within the case.
“The felony record could be very detailed, filled with proof of systematic, very various and completely monstrous torture practices,” Baudouin stated.
WHY IS THE TRIAL IN FRANCE?
Patrick and Mazen Dabbagh had twin French-Syrian nationality, which enabled French magistrates to pursue the case. The probe in their disappearance began in 2015 when Obeida Dabbagh, Mazen’s brother, testified to investigators already inspecting battle crimes in Syria.
Obeida Dabbagh lives in France together with his spouse, Hanane, and may be a celebration within the case. In line with the trial indictment, noticed via The Related Press, he informed French investigators that 3 or 4 squaddies got here for Patrick round 11 p.m. on Nov. 3, 2013, all the way through the peak of Arab Spring-inspired anti-government protests that have been met via a brutal crackdown. The warriors known themselves as contributors of a Syrian Air Drive intelligence department. Obeida additionally testified they searched the home, taking cell phones, computer systems and cash.
They got here again the following night time for Mazen Dabbagh, who was once 54 and labored as a counselor at a French highschool in Damascus, and likewise took his new automotive, the brother stated.
Their loss of life certificate stated Patrick died Jan. 21, 2014, and Mazen on Nov. 25, 2017, however didn’t say how or the place.
THE TRIAL EXPECTED TO EXPOSE TORTURE
French investigating magistrates gathered proof from those that abandoned the Syrian authorities and armed forces, and jail survivors as they constructed the case.
Attesting anonymously, survivors’ accounts discuss within the indictment of rape and of being denied meals and water; of beatings at the toes, knees and in other places with whips, cables and truncheons; of electrical shocks and burnings with acid or boiling water; of being suspended from the ceiling for hours or days.
Investigators additionally studied photographs supplied via a Syrian policeman, who anonymously became over images of 1000’s of torture sufferers.
Cameras are usually banned from French legal trials, however this one might be filmed for historic file.
ANOTHER FRENCH PROBE TARGETS PRESIDENT ASSAD
In a separate investigation, French magistrates have additionally centered President Assad himself however face questions on whether or not he advantages from presidential immunity.
Magistrates are investigating chemical guns’ assaults that killed greater than 1,000 other folks and injured 1000’s of others within the suburbs of Damascus in 2013. They issued world arrest warrants for Assad, his brother Maher Assad, commander of the 4th Armored Department, and two Syrian military generals — Ghassan Abbas and Bassam al-Hassan — for alleged complicity in battle crimes and crimes in opposition to humanity.
The French probe was once opened in 2021 in keeping with a legal grievance via assault survivors. The investigation is being performed underneath the primary of common jurisdiction, which argues that during some instances, crimes will also be pursued out of doors the international locations the place they happen.
The Syrian authorities and its allies have denied duty for the assaults.
The French warrants, very uncommon for a serving global chief, have been noticed as a robust sign in opposition to Assad’s management at a time when some international locations have welcomed him again into the diplomatic fold. Sufferers’ attorneys hailed the warrants as “a the most important milestone within the combat in opposition to impunity.”
The Paris appeals courtroom is weighing whether or not Assad has absolute immunity as head of state. French prosecutors requested it to rule on that query at a closed listening to Might 15.
That process does no longer have an effect on the warrants for Assad’s brother and the generals.
OTHER COUNTRIES ALSO TAKING ACTION
In March, Swiss prosecutors indicted Rifat Assad, the president’s uncle and a former Syrian vp, for allegedly ordering homicide and torture greater than 4 many years in the past to weigh down an rebellion via the Muslim Brotherhood, an Islamist motion, within the town of Hama, the place 1000’s have been killed.
A courtroom in Stockholm put a former Syrian military basic who lives in Sweden on trial in April for his alleged function in battle crimes in 2012.
Courts in Germany discovered two former Syrian squaddies accountable in 2021 and 2022 of crimes in opposition to humanity. One was once sentenced to lifestyles imprisonment, the opposite to 4 1/2 years for complicity. That they had claimed refugee standing in Germany ahead of former detainees known them there. They have been attempted underneath the primary of common jurisdiction.
___
Surk reported from Great, France. Related Press creator Kareem Chehayeb in Beirut contributed to this file.
apnews.com
